Nick Baker asked, “Why don't plants get cancer, or do they?”
Dr Sarah McLusky (ex-plant pathologist) replies
“To answer your stump the scientist question, plants do get cancer, sort of... In response to infection by pathogens many plants produce masses of undifferentiated (non-specialised) cells called 'callus'. These are basically the same as tumours in animals. The callus is part of the plant's disease resistance response and an attempt to contain the infection.
'Plant cancer' is more familiar to gardeners as 'canker' in woody trees and shrubs - canker describes a set of symptoms, including the callus formation described above, rather than an infection caused by a particular pathogen.”
Also NESTA’s own Kamini Plaha adds
“Don’t know if this counts but I think/believe the reason why plants don’t get cancer is because they regulate their own growth.”
We also had another stumper. Caroline told us
“My son has been given some old science exam papers to practice with over the Easter holidays, he has common entrance exams in June.
One question was: How do you extract vinegar from a salt and vinegar crisp?
He knows how to extract the salt but not the vinegar. I have searched over the Internet but cannot find anything relevant. Could you please help to answer that question for a science mad boy who is stumped?”
Well according to Richard Bryan
”I assume that this is not an attempt to separate the vinegar but merely to convert a salt & vinegar crisp into just a salted crisp. (Hmmmmm not sure about that. Ed)
This method relies on the fact that vinegar is an acid (ethanoic acid) and can therefore be removed by reacting it with a suitable base. An example of such a base is bicarbonate of soda (sodium hydrogencarbonate). Open the packet, add one teaspoonful of bicarbonate and shake the bag. Leave for an hour for the reaction to happen and then try one of the crisps. If there is still a vinegary taste, just add another teaspoon of bicarbonate and wait a bit longer.
Water is one of the products of the reaction so you will get soggy crisps unfortunately. The other products are carbon dioxide gas and sodium ethanoate. In large doses sodium ethanoate is harmful so it is not a good idea to eat too many crisps!”
Interesting…
And Dr Alan P Glaze further adds to the argument by stating, “It's possible that there is no vinegar.............. - sodium diacetate (E262) is used as a 'vinegar' flavouring agent.“
What?! After all that effort? Are you going to tell Richard Bryan or shall we?
So thank you one and all. On this occasion, and for two questions, the scientist was NOT stumped!
If you can help or have a burning question of your own then send us an email with STUMP THE SCIENTIST in the subject line to planet-science.news@nesta.org.uk